Discovering that a former employer is giving you a negative reference is alarming. Your first question is usually: can they do this? Your second is: what can I do about it? The answers depend on what exactly is being said, whether it is true, and which state you are in.
This article explains the legal framework around employment references, what constitutes a potentially actionable reference, and what practical steps you can take if you believe a former employer is damaging your career prospects. Note that this is general information only and not legal advice. If you believe you have a claim, consult a licensed employment attorney in your state.
The most important thing to understand about employment reference law is that truth is an absolute defense. A former employer who honestly and accurately describes your performance, attendance, conduct, or the circumstances of your departure is generally protected from liability, even if that information is unflattering to you.
This means that a former manager who truthfully tells a prospective employer that you were terminated for performance reasons, that you had a pattern of tardiness, or that you were difficult to work with is not doing anything illegal, even if that information costs you a job offer.
Where former employers can get into legal trouble is when they cross into false statements, protected disclosures, or statements made with malicious intent.
Defamation in the employment reference context occurs when a former employer makes a false statement of fact about you to a prospective employer, that statement damages your reputation or career prospects, and the statement was made negligently or with knowledge that it was false.
For a defamation claim to succeed in most states, you generally need to establish all of the following:
Proving defamation is difficult. You need to know what was said, which requires documentation. You need to prove it was false, which requires evidence. And you need to demonstrate that the statement caused your harm, which can be complicated when employers rarely confirm the reason they chose another candidate.
Most states have enacted laws that provide employers with immunity for good-faith reference disclosures. These statutes vary significantly by state but generally protect employers who share reference information honestly and without malice.
Under these immunity statutes, an employer who provides a reference in good faith is protected even if the information later turns out to be inaccurate, as long as they were not deliberately lying or acting with intent to harm you. The practical effect of these statutes is that the bar for a successful defamation claim against a former employer is relatively high in most states.
However, immunity statutes typically do not protect employers who make statements they know to be false, who disclose information with malicious intent, or who share information they have no reasonable basis to believe is true.
Regardless of immunity statutes, there are categories of information that employers are generally prohibited from disclosing during a reference call. Sharing the following can expose an employer to significant liability:
Even if a former employer is saying something illegal about you during reference calls, you will never know it happened unless you take steps to find out. Prospective employers are not required to tell you what they heard or why they chose another candidate. The only way to know is to find out directly what is being said.
Before you can take any action, you need documentation of what was actually said. A written transcript of the reference call is the foundation of any legal consultation or dispute. Without knowing exactly what was said, an attorney has very little to work with.
If your transcript reveals statements that appear false, defamatory, or legally prohibited, your next step is a consultation with a licensed employment attorney who specializes in employment law in your state. Many employment attorneys offer free initial consultations.
Bring your reference transcript to the consultation. The attorney will evaluate whether the statements are actionable, what your realistic legal options are, and what the potential remedies might include.
In many cases, a cease and desist letter from an attorney is an effective first step. A formal letter from legal counsel demanding that the former employer stop making specific statements often produces results without requiring litigation. Employers who receive such letters typically consult their own legal team and may significantly curtail what they say in future reference calls.
Even if a former employer's conduct is technically actionable, litigation is expensive, time-consuming, and uncertain. For many job seekers, the most practical response to a bad reference is to manage around it rather than pursue legal action. This means removing the problematic employer from your active reference list, steering prospective employers toward contacts who will advocate strongly for you, and preparing honest context for any gaps or concerns that arise during the hiring process.
You cannot address a problem you do not know exists. Whether your response is legal action, a cease and desist letter, or simply updating your reference list, everything starts with knowing exactly what your former employer is saying. A Reference Recon check gives you that information before it costs you another opportunity.
Former employers have more latitude to speak about you than most people realize, but that latitude has real limits. False statements, malicious disclosures, and protected class information can all give rise to legal claims. The challenge is that you cannot enforce rights you do not know you have, against conduct you cannot see.
The first step is always the same: find out exactly what is being said. Everything else follows from there.
Reference Recon anonymously contacts your former employer and delivers a full written transcript of the reference call. Starting at $39.99.
Start My Reference Check